Premier's Thanksgiving Wine Guide

Red Wines

You'll definitely want some red wines on-hand for your Thanksgiving dinner, but which bottles pair best? Generally speaking, Pinot Noirs are a great match for turkey, cranberry sauce and all of the fixings. Zinfandels are also a great option, pairing well with both dark and light meat and complementing flavorful side dishes like stuffing and glazed carrots. Here's a collection of some of our favorite reds for pairing with your Thanksgiving feast.

• Premier Select

  Hill & Blade

  Hill & Blade Zinfandel

  750ml

  Compare at: $14.99

  $9.99

  AMH

  Hill & Blade Zinfandel 2021 showcases the bold character of Lodi's sun-drenched vineyards, where old-vine fruit yields ripe blackberry, spiced plum, and a whisper of black pepper. At 15% ABV, this Central Valley red delivers rich, velvety texture and a warm, generous finish—an unabashedly robust expression of California Zinfandel.

• Premier Select

  Veramente

  Veramente Rosso 16

  750ml

  Compare at: $19.99

  $11.99

  AMH

  Veramente Rosso 16 is a bold Italian table wine crafted for those who savor intensity. With a robust 16% ABV, this red delivers rich, full-bodied character and warmth in every glass. An approachable yet powerful sip, perfect for those seeking authentic Italian flavor with a little extra punch.

• Premier Select

  The Xtrovert

  The Introvert Pinot Noir Reserve

  750ml

  WE 92

  Compare at: $14.99

  $11.99

  AMH

  The Introvert Pinot Noir Reserve 2023 from The Xtrovert offers quiet complexity in every glass—California-grown fruit yielding silky red cherry, rose petal, and subtle spice notes. Elegant yet approachable, this 14.5% ABV red rewards contemplative sipping, proving the best conversations sometimes begin with a moment of stillness.

• Premier Select

  Castello Sonnino

  Castello Sonnino Chianti Montespertoli

  750ml

  JS 90

  Compare at: $17.99

  $14.99

  AMH

  Crafted from estate-grown Sangiovese in the storied hills of Chianti Montespertoli, this 2022 red from Castello Sonnino offers vibrant cherry fruit, subtle earthy spice, and bright Tuscan acidity. Elegant and food-friendly at 13.5% ABV, it's a true expression of centuries-old winemaking heritage, perfect alongside pasta, roasted meats, or aged cheeses.

• Premier Select

  Frog's Leap

  Frog's Leap Jeremiah Cabernet Sauvignon

  750ml

  Compare at: $54.99

  $34.99

  AMH

  Frog's Leap Jeremiah Cabernet Sauvignon 2023 is a pure expression of Napa Valley terroir, crafted from 100% Cabernet Sauvignon grapes. Elegant and vibrant, this North Coast red offers refined tannins and balanced acidity at a modest 13.5% ABV, reflecting the winery's commitment to organic farming and old-world restraint over modern excess.

• Premier Select

  Fairweather

  Fairweather Los Carneros Pinot Noir

  750ml

  WE 91

  Compare at: $24.99

  $16.99

  AMH

  The 2023 Fairweather Los Carneros Pinot Noir showcases the cool, fog-kissed terroir of Sonoma's Carneros AVA, delivering bright red cherry and wild strawberry notes layered with hints of baking spice and earthy undertones. Silky tannins and lively acidity make this 14% ABV red a graceful, food-friendly expression of California Pinot Noir at its finest.

• Premier Select

  Skaggs Carneros

  Skaggs Carneros Pinot Noir

  750ml

  JS 93

  Compare at: $24.99

  $17.99

  AMH
• Premier Select

  Pierre de Fontval

  Pierre de Fontval Châteauneuf-du-Pape

  750ml

  SP 92

  Compare at: $59.99

  $49.99

  AMH
• Premier Select

  Russian River Vineyards

  Russian River Vineyards Classic Cuvée Pinot Noir

  750ml

  Compare at: $24.99

  $17.99

  AMH

  The 2023 Russian River Vineyards Classic Cuvée Pinot Noir showcases the cool-climate elegance of Sonoma County's celebrated Russian River Valley. Silky and vibrant, it offers layers of red cherry, wild strawberry, and subtle spice, framed by supple tannins and bright acidity—an approachable yet refined expression of California's finest Pinot Noir terroir.

• Premier Select

  Anther & Bloom

  Anther & Bloom Willamette Valley Pinot Noir

  750ml

  Compare at: $24.99

  $16.99

  OP

  Anther & Bloom's 2023 Willamette Valley Pinot Noir captures the essence of Oregon's celebrated terroir, offering silky red fruit, delicate floral notes, and a whisper of earthy spice. Elegant and vibrant at 13.5% ABV, this graceful red is a testament to the region's cool-climate finesse—perfect for both quiet evenings and refined celebrations.

• Premier Select

  Gabriel Meffre

  Terres de Galets Côtes du Rhône

  750ml

  Compare at: $16.99

  $11.99

  OP
• Premier Select

  Tenuta Sant' Anna

  Tenuta Sant'Anna Valpolicella

  750ml

  Compare at: $19.99

  $14.99

  OP

  Bright and effortlessly charming, the 2022 Tenuta Sant'Anna Valpolicella showcases the signature elegance of Corvina from Veneto's storied hills. Expect juicy cherry, wild berry, and subtle spice notes wrapped in soft tannins, finishing with a fresh, food-friendly lift. A versatile, authentic taste of Valpolicella at 12.5% ABV.

• Premier Select

  Hologram

  Hologram Cabernet Sauvignon

  750ml

  JS 92

  Compare at: $29.99

  $21.99

  OP

  Hologram Cabernet Sauvignon 2023 captures the bold elegance of Napa Valley in every glass, showcasing rich dark fruit, velvety tannins, and subtle oak nuances. This 14.5% ABV red table wine offers a polished, layered profile that reflects the prestige of California's premier winemaking region.

• Premier Select

  Gearbox Wines

  Gearbox Pinot Noir

  750ml

  Compare at: $16.99

  $12.99

  OP

  Gearbox Pinot Noir 2023 delivers California elegance in every glass, showcasing bright red cherry, subtle spice, and silky tannins. At 13.8% ABV, this beautifully balanced red wine offers refined complexity and approachable charm—an ideal companion for both everyday indulgence and special occasions alike.

• Premier Select

  Beau Vigne

  Beau Vigne Hero Red

  750ml

  Compare at: $29.99

  $19.99

  OP

  Beau Vigne Hero Red 2023 is a California statement wine, blending 62% Cabernet Sauvignon with 24% Merlot for structured depth and lush fruit. At 14.5% ABV, this bold table red delivers rich, velvety layers with a polished finish—an effortlessly sophisticated choice for any occasion.

• Premier Select

  Sonoma Bespoke Adobe Flats Vineyard Pinot Noir

  750ml

  Compare at: $19.99

  $14.99

  OP

  Sourced from the fog-kissed Adobe Flats Vineyard in Petaluma Gap, this 2024 Pinot Noir showcases the cool-climate elegance Sonoma is celebrated for. Silky tannins frame layers of red cherry, wild berry, and subtle spice, culminating in a graceful, lingering finish. At 14% ABV, it's a refined expression of California terroir.

• Premier Select

  Casa Vinicola Botter

  Gran Passione Rosso

  750ml

  Compare at: $15.99

  $11.99

  OP

  Gran Passione Rosso 2023 from Casa Vinicola Botter marries Merlot and Corvina in a bold, velvety expression of Veneto's winemaking artistry. Rich dark fruit, subtle spice, and a lush, rounded finish reveal traces of appassimento influence, delivering an intense yet approachable red at 14% ABV—perfect for hearty meals or indulgent evenings.

• Premier Select

  Beau Vigne

  Beau Vigne Heritage Cabernet Sauvignon

  750ml

  Compare at: $29.99

  $19.99

  OP

  Beau Vigne Heritage Cabernet Sauvignon 2023 showcases California's North Coast at its finest, delivering rich layers of dark fruit, subtle oak, and refined tannins. This 14% ABV red embodies the region's legacy of exceptional winemaking, offering a bold yet balanced expression perfect for cellaring or savoring alongside a hearty meal.

• 

  Chateau Buffalo

  Chateau Buffalo 999 Broadway

  750ml

  Compare at: $10.99

  $9.99

  OP

  Chateau Buffalo 999 Broadway celebrates New York's Concord grape heritage with bold, jammy fruit character and lush, sweet appeal. This flavorful fruit wine offers a nostalgic nod to classic American vineyards, delivering vibrant, juicy richness in every glass—an approachable, crowd-pleasing pour perfect for casual sipping or creative cocktails.